The Patriots lost their first set 25-22 to the Red Raiders, but won the next three sets to defeat Fairport 3-1.
Penfield won sets two and three 25-23, and won set for 25-18.
Mike Marcy led the way for Penfield with 16 kills and seven digs, while Evan Ingerick recorded 38 assists and three kills. Penfield had a 65% side out percentage, 83% in the fourth set.
Fairport’s Carter Dittman racked up 12 kills and Mason Yusko had nine.