Arcadia opened the scoring just eight minutes into the game when Chris Collili’s found Tyler Lewandowski behind the defense to give the Titans a 1-0 lead.
Brockport evened the score before halftime as Colby Wharram cleaned up a scrum off a Blue Devil corner.
Things got crazy in the final 20 minutes.
The Blue Devils took their first lead of the night as Calvin Moulton’s pass made it threw a slew of defenders to Vander Hart who scored with 19 minutes remaining.
Lewandowski tied the game with his second of the night just seven minutes after that.
Eight minutes remaining in regulation, Sergia Garcia picked up a lose ball and slid it into the back of the net as the Titans went back on top 3-2.
Two minutes to go, Ben Leach sent a volley to the far post where Hart’s head was waiting for it.
Hart’s second goal of the night with 1:52 remaining forced overtime.
After two scoreless ten minute frames the game came down to penalty kicks.
It was tied 3-3 after four rounds of PKs when Caleb Peck scored for Brockport to put the Blue Devils up a goal.
Arcadia’s final attempt was stopped by Peyton Young to send Brockport to the Class A1 final where they will face Brighton.